After the initial rush of information found about Ophelia, I seem to be running low on leads. A few promising trails came to nothing and frustratingly my attempts to reach out to the seller of the 2nd book have fallen on deaf ears.
However I have found out the following information…
Death and Burial
Ophelia died on the 18th October, 1915 of Pulmonary Meningitis (TB Meningitis) and was buried in Burnopfield a few days later. Her Father Dr John Stuart was buried alongside her on January 14th 1916. The location of their gravestone is unfortunately not recorded. Many thanks to the Vicar and the volunteers at the St James, Burnopfield church for checking the records. I’ll probably visit the church at somepoint to see if I can find the gravestone.
Multitalented
On her death certificate Ophelia is referred to as being a student of music, which surprised me – new mission is to find out what instrument(s) she played.
A Medical Family

Ophelia’s father, Dr Stuart, left money to his wife’s brother, James Fowler Tocher, after his death.

James Fowler Tocher was a celebrated chemist – another health related professional – which explains why there are so many medical products in the scrapbook. Her father was a doctor, the aunt who lived with them was a pharmacist and her other uncle, Robert, as also a chemist.
Ophelia’s Aunt Eliza, who is registered as staying at the family home in Tanfield during the 1911 census, was noted to be a ‘dispenser’ on the form and a ‘laboratory assistant’ on her death certificate (she died in 1917).


Christie, Alexander; James Fowler Tocher; Art & Heritage Collections, Robert Gordon University; http://www.artuk.org/artworks/james-fowler-tocher-105304
The Missing Pages
Previously to starting this project I’d been under the impression that antiques dealers were history buffs who made their interest a paying hobby/ career. Given this rather romanticised idea of the job I really thought that the two dealers involved with these books would have loved to know more about the books that had been under their care. However getting information from these sources has failed to turn up any information in one case or a response from the other (four emails and a direct message on Ebay – I think anymore might count as harassment).
My initial assessment of my book was that some pages had been excised and that they had potentially been resold separately due to them perhaps containing something of higher value than the rest of the book (‘A Penny Black?’ wondered a friend). However, as I sat staring at the book as I have so many nights – looking for a hitherto overlooked clue, I noticed that the same number of pages were missing from both sides of the book. Then noticed that the remnants of the cut off pages were of much higher quality paper than the main pages. It appears that Ophelia had cut out the original pages of the book, perhaps feeling that her style had developed since this earlier book, and stitched in the pages from another book that she obviously felt warranted the leather bound cover. This made me smile – I had the complete book! There were no other pages to trace, what a relief. It also fits the image I have in mind of Ophelia – a very meticulous, precise kind of person, such a perfectionist that she would cut the cover off of a lesser book to house something she thought represented her work better. It’s a familiar feeling, as the tower of half started sketchbooks in my study will testify to.
New Lines of Enquiry
A few items on my to-do list
- A reddit user suggested looking into the man in the photograph featured on ‘The Other Book’ – surrounded by stamps, as this might be a penpal or romantic connection.
- The book features many references to global exhibitions – perhaps her father was a sales rep for a pharmaceutical company.
- Researching individual brands featured in the scrap.
If anyone has any suggestions for new lines of enquiry or has any questions regarding Ophelia or the book, please feel free to get in touch via the comments.
Hi I have just read your article about Ophelia RHS Stuart she was my fathers cousin, her mother Sarah lived with my grandparents, until her death, in Edinburgh. I had no idea these books existed and am so pleased to learn you have one and just how much it means to you. I will share this information with other members of the family to see if they have heard of these books. Elizabeth Stuart (maiden name Tocher) coincidence that I have the same surname!
LikeLike
Hi, thanks so much for getting in touch! I tried to email you back but the email attached to this account went to the wrong person.
If you or any family member would like to see the book sometime, I’d be happy to meet up for a coffee in Edinburgh somewhere.
I wondered if you had any photographs of Ophelia you could share? I’d love to put a face to the name.
Thanks,
Evonne
LikeLike